Geico is our top car insurance company pick in New York. Following Geico are Travelers, NYCM, and Progressive.

Progressive scored 5 out of 5 stars in our analysis of car insurance companies. It offers below-average rates for most driving profiles, including good drivers, seniors and those with a DUI. Complaint ...

You may wonder how Progressive and AAA car insurance compare as you look for new car insurance. Progressive is available nationwide, has competitive rates, and provides a variety of auto insurance ...